In honor of the pending Toad the Wet Sprocket show at the Ponte Vedra Concert Hall along with the release of their new cd New Constellation I decided to consider what my perfect setlist would be if the band asked. Like any fan the easy answer would be “the entire catalog no matter how long it took” but in keeping with reality (because being asked to create a setlist qualifies as such) the number of songs will be consistent with their standard concert offering but not exact. In other words I had to add one more beyond the limit.

The way it worked out it is not too far off what they might be playing. While the obscure songs have an appeal the truth is their more popular songs have always played well live and there is something to be said of the crowd singing “Walk on the Ocean” and “All I Want” in unison. And as staples, you have to hear “Windmills” and “Fall Down”.

Fellow fans, share your thoughts.

1. New Constellation

2. Brother

3. Is it for Me?

4. I’ll Bet on You

5. I Think About

6. Rings

7. One Little Girl

8. Stupid

9. California Wasted

10. Get What You Want

11. Whatever I Fear

12. Windmills

13. Little Heaven

14. So Alive

15. All I Want

16. Crowing

17. Fall Down

Encore

18. The Moment

19. Enough

20. Humble/Know Me

21. Walk on the Ocean

22. Throw it All Away